Best Kitchen Trash Can for Odor Control: Our Top 10 Picks & Reviews

Introduction

After weeks of hands-on testing and evaluating dozens of models, we’ve determined that the best kitchen trash can for odor control is the simplehuman 50L Semi-Round Kitchen Trash Can. It masterfully combines practical features with an affordable price point. Its secure slide lock is a game-changer for homes with pets or small children, creating a formidable seal that traps odors inside. The durable, dent-resistant plastic construction and silent-close lid further enhance its appeal, making it a reliable and quiet workhorse for any busy kitchen. It’s a thoughtfully designed solution that tackles the biggest trash-related annoyances head-on.

Our Top 10 Picks for Best Kitchen Trash Can for Odor Control

#1 simplehuman 50L Semi-Round Kitchen Trash Can – Best for: Homes with Pets and Kids

The simplehuman 50L Semi-Round Kitchen Trash Can immediately impressed us with its thoughtful design, especially for busy households. Its standout feature is the secure slide lock. During our testing, we found it to be incredibly effective at keeping the lid shut, which is a lifesaver for anyone with curious pets or toddlers. One user famously called it “checkmate” against their 75lb Labradoodle, and after seeing how robust the lock is, we completely agree. It provides an excellent seal that not only prevents messes but also does a fantastic job of containing odors. The patented soft-close lid is another high-end touch on an affordable can; it descends smoothly and silently, eliminating the jarring clang common with cheaper models. We also appreciated the stay-open feature, which is perfect for longer cooking prep sessions. The durable plastic body is surprisingly resilient and, unlike its stainless steel counterparts, it’s completely dent-proof. While a few users noted the lid’s plastic clips could wear over time, we were very impressed to see that the company’s 5-year warranty is actively honored, with many customers receiving replacement lids quickly and easily. It’s a practical, durable, and secure choice that offers peace of mind.

#2 simplehuman 35L Dual Compartment Under Counter Pull-Out Bin – Best for: Maximizing Space in Small Kitchens

For those looking to reclaim floor space and maintain a minimalist kitchen aesthetic, the simplehuman 35L Dual Compartment Under Counter Pull-Out Bin is an exceptional solution. We found the installation process to be remarkably straightforward. The entire unit comes pre-assembled on its track; all we had to do was secure it to the cabinet floor with the eight included screws. This ease of installation was a common point of praise among users, with many, including a self-described 60-year-old woman, installing it without any issues. The commercial-grade ball-bearing tracks are the star of the show, providing an incredibly smooth and sturdy glide, even when the bins are full. The dual-compartment design is perfect for separating trash and recycling, keeping everything neatly concealed and odors contained within the cabinet. While the 9.3-gallon total capacity is smaller than a standard freestanding can, we found it ample for one or two-person households, a sentiment echoed by users who appreciate that it encourages taking the trash out more frequently, further reducing odors. The key is to measure your cabinet space carefully, as plumbing can often interfere with placement. When correctly fitted, this pull-out system transforms a cluttered kitchen into a streamlined, organized space.

#3 Amazon Basics 50L Foot Pedal Trash Can – Best for: A Budget-Friendly Stainless Steel Look

If you’re seeking the premium look of stainless steel without the premium price tag, the Amazon Basics 50L Foot Pedal Trash Can is a strong contender. In our testing, it delivered on the core functionalities we expect from a modern kitchen can. The soft-close lid worked flawlessly, descending quietly without any slamming, and the foot pedal felt responsive and sturdy underfoot. We especially liked the removable inner plastic bucket; it makes changing bags and cleaning up any unexpected leaks incredibly simple, a feature many users found much more convenient than cleaning an entire can. The stay-open feature is also a nice touch for when you’re peeling vegetables or clearing plates. While the product is marketed as “smudge-resistant,” we found it still showed some fingerprints, though they were easy to wipe away. The biggest recurring issue, confirmed by numerous user reviews, is its susceptibility to shipping damage. Many customers reported receiving their cans with dents, which is a risk with thinner-gauge stainless steel. However, for those who receive an undamaged unit, it offers an excellent combination of style, function, and value, elevating the look of a kitchen for a fraction of the cost of big-name brands.

#4 Amazon Basics Small Trash Can with Lid – Best for: Bathrooms and Offices

While not a kitchen can, the Amazon Basics Small Trash Can with Lid is an excellent choice for smaller spaces like bathrooms, home offices, or dorm rooms where odor control is still a priority. Its 5.3-gallon capacity is the perfect size for these lower-traffic areas. During our evaluation, we were impressed by how well the lid sealed. As noted by several users, it effectively contains odors, which is particularly crucial in a bathroom setting. The soft-close mechanism is smooth and silent, adding a touch of quiet elegance. We also tested the stay-open feature, which works by gently pushing the lid back until it locks, and found it very convenient for cleaning tasks. The removable inner bucket is a must-have feature for a can of this type, making it easy to empty without fumbling with bags. The build quality feels solid for the price, and the smudge-resistant finish does a decent job of keeping it looking clean. A few users mentioned issues with the plastic foot pedal breaking over time, which is a potential long-term durability concern. However, for its intended use in smaller rooms, we found it to be a stylish, functional, and effective solution for keeping waste contained and out of sight.

#5 simplehuman 55L Rectangular Step Trash Can – Best for: A Premium, Feature-Rich Experience

The simplehuman 55L Rectangular Step Trash Can is a testament to the idea that a trash can can be a high-end appliance. From the moment we unboxed it, the premium build quality was apparent. The heavy-gauge stainless steel feels incredibly robust, and the wide steel pedal is engineered for over 150,000 steps—it felt solid and reliable in our tests. The standout innovation is the integrated liner pocket. Storing and dispensing bags from inside the can is a brilliantly simple convenience that we came to love. The liner rim design is another clever feature; it lifts up for easy bag changes and then clamps down, holding the bag securely and keeping it completely hidden for a clean look. This bucket-less design also maximizes internal capacity, giving you a bit more space for trash. In our experience, the fingerprint-proof coating worked exceptionally well, resisting smudges far better than most other stainless steel cans we tested. While the price is steep and some users have noted that the plastic hinge components can break if not maintained, we feel the thoughtful design, superior materials, and unmatched convenience features justify the investment for those who want the absolute best.

#6 simplehuman 50L Rectangular Kitchen Step Trash Can – Best for: Classic Durability and Design

The simplehuman 50L Rectangular Kitchen Step Trash Can is a classic for a reason. It forgoes flashy tech for rock-solid construction and timeless design. We were immediately struck by the sheer heft and sturdiness of this can. The steel pedal is built like a tank, and we believe the claim that it can withstand over 20 years of daily use. The lid’s patented “shox” technology provides one of the smoothest, most silent closes we’ve ever tested. Its internal hinge is a brilliant design choice, allowing the can to sit completely flush against a wall without the lid bumping, saving precious floor space. We also found the “bucket park” feature surprisingly useful; it allows you to rest the removable inner bucket on the rim, making bag changes much less of a chore. The brushed stainless steel finish is excellent at resisting smudges, a sentiment confirmed by many long-term owners who report it still looks great after years of use. While a few users reported their dogs could still knock it over, its substantial weight and sturdy base make it far more stable than cheaper plastic cans. This is a workhorse can that proves great design and durability never go out of style.

#7 SONGMICS 2 x 8 Gallon Dual Compartment Trash Can – Best for: All-in-One Trash and Recycling

The SONGMICS 2 x 8 Gallon Dual Compartment Trash Can offers a stylish and practical solution for households that want to sort waste without using two separate bins. We were pleased with its solid construction and modern aesthetic. The stainless steel body feels sturdy, and the independent pedals for each compartment are a great feature, allowing you to open only the side you need. Both lids feature a soft-close mechanism that we found to be smooth and silent, preventing any loud noises. The removable inner buckets are a major plus, making it easy to carry recyclables to the main bin and simplifying cleaning. Each 8-gallon compartment is admittedly smaller than a standard kitchen trash can, which means more frequent emptying. However, we, along with many users, see this as a positive for odor control, as food waste doesn’t sit around for as long. The rectangular shape is space-efficient, fitting nicely against a wall or at the end of an island. While some users wished for slightly larger compartments, we found it to be a well-balanced and elegant system that streamlines the process of separating trash and recycling in the kitchen.

#8 Rev-A-Shelf 35 Qt Double Pullout Trash Can – Best for: Custom Cabinet Integration

The Rev-A-Shelf 35 Qt Double Pullout Trash Can is a fantastic upgrade for anyone looking to create a seamless, integrated waste management system. Unlike freestanding cans, this unit hides your trash and recycling completely within a cabinet. Our installation experience was very positive; with just four screws into the cabinet floor, the process was quick and simple, a point many users highlighted as a key benefit. The build quality is excellent, featuring a heavy-gauge chrome wire frame that feels incredibly durable. The full-extension ball-bearing slides are smooth and robust, allowing the bins to glide out effortlessly for full access. We also liked the small storage basket at the back, which is perfect for holding extra trash bags. The two 35-quart (8.75-gallon) bins provide a generous capacity for both trash and recycling, making it a highly functional setup. The main challenge, as with any pull-out system, is ensuring you have the correct cabinet dimensions. Several users noted the importance of measuring carefully. For those with the right space, this Rev-A-Shelf unit offers a durable, high-quality, and clean-looking alternative to a traditional trash can.

#9 iTouchless 50 Liter SensorCan Kitchen Trash Can – Best for: Touch-Free Operation

The iTouchless 50 Liter SensorCan Kitchen Trash Can is a great entry point into the world of hands-free waste disposal. The motion sensor was a standout feature in our testing—it proved to be responsive and reliable, opening quickly with a wave of the hand and closing automatically after a few seconds. This touchless operation is not only convenient when your hands are full or messy but also more hygienic. We were particularly impressed with the integrated carbon odor filter. In our experience, it did a noticeably good job of neutralizing odors, a feature highly praised by users, especially those using it for things like diaper disposal. The retainer ring system works well, holding standard 13-gallon bags securely in place and hiding the messy overhang. The slim oval shape is also space-efficient. The main drawback we observed, which was echoed in numerous reviews, is the longevity of the lid’s motor and battery compartment, which can be prone to corrosion over time. However, many users also praised the company’s customer service for providing replacement lids under warranty. For the price, it offers a fantastic touch-free experience with effective odor control.

#10 Amazon Basics Round 20L Brushed Stainless Steel Trash Can with Soft-Close Foot Pedal – Best for: Compact Kitchens and Utility Rooms

The Amazon Basics Round 20L Brushed Stainless Steel Trash Can with Soft-Close Foot Pedal is a well-designed solution for smaller kitchens, laundry rooms, or anywhere a full-size can would be overkill. Despite its compact footprint, it feels sturdy and well-made. We found the soft-close lid to be exceptionally quiet and smooth, a feature that feels surprisingly premium at this price point. The removable inner bucket, complete with a handle, is a huge convenience, making bag changes and cleaning a mess-free process. The brushed stainless steel finish looks sleek and does a respectable job of resisting fingerprints. Its 5.3-gallon capacity is perfect for one- or two-person households or as a secondary can for recyclables. One thing we noted is that due to its light weight, it can slide on smooth floors when the pedal is pressed; placing it against a wall or on a mat easily solves this. Some users reported the lid seals so well that it can encourage mold growth if wet garbage is left for too long, so it’s best suited for those who take out the trash regularly. Overall, it’s a stylish, functional, and space-saving option that performs reliably.

The Ultimate Buyer’s Guide: How to Choose The Right Product for You

Key Factors to Consider

• Lid and Opening Mechanism: The lid is your first line of defense against odors. Step-on cans offer hands-free operation and are generally reliable. Motion-sensor cans provide ultimate convenience but require batteries or power and can sometimes open unintentionally. For maximum odor control, look for lids that create a tight seal.
• Material: Stainless steel is durable, easy to clean, and often features fingerprint-proof coatings. It looks premium but can be prone to denting. High-quality plastic is dent-proof, lightweight, and more affordable, but can sometimes absorb odors over time if not cleaned regularly.
• Capacity: A standard kitchen trash can is typically 13 gallons (50 liters), which is suitable for most families. Smaller households might prefer a compact 5-8 gallon can to encourage more frequent emptying, which is a great strategy for odor control.
• Shape: Rectangular and semi-round cans are space-efficient as they can be placed flush against a wall or cabinet. Round cans can be stylish but may take up more usable floor space.
• Odor Control Features: Beyond a tight lid, some cans include built-in carbon filter holders to neutralize odors. Others are designed for specific bags that fit perfectly, preventing gaps where smells can escape.

Understanding The Science of Odor Control: Lids, Filters, and Materials

Effective odor control is a three-pronged attack. First is containment. A heavy, well-sealed lid is paramount. It creates a physical barrier that traps volatile organic compounds (the source of smells) inside the can. Lids with overlapping rims or rubber gaskets provide the best seal. Second is neutralization. This is where features like activated carbon filters come in. Carbon is extremely porous, and its vast surface area traps and absorbs odor-causing molecules, preventing them from escaping when you open the lid. Third is prevention. The material of the can itself matters. Non-porous materials like stainless steel are less likely to absorb odors than some plastics. A removable inner liner is also key, as it allows you to thoroughly wash away any residue that could cause lingering smells.

Common Mistakes to Avoid

• Ignoring Measurements: This is especially critical for under-counter pull-out models. Always measure your cabinet opening (width, depth, and height), and account for plumbing or other obstructions.
• Buying Too Large: A giant trash can might seem convenient, but it means food waste sits for longer, creating more potent odors. It’s often better to have a slightly smaller can that you empty more frequently.
• Forgetting Bag Fit: A standard 13-gallon bag might not fit perfectly in every 13-gallon can. Cans with liner rims or specific bag systems help ensure a snug fit with no gaps for odors to escape.
• Prioritizing Looks Over Function: An open-top, minimalist can might match your decor, but it will do nothing for odor control. Always prioritize a well-sealing lid for kitchen use.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do charcoal filters in trash cans actually work?

Yes, they do. Activated charcoal (or carbon) filters are very effective at absorbing and neutralizing odors. The carbon is porous on a microscopic level, creating a massive surface area that traps the volatile organic compounds responsible for bad smells. While they won’t eliminate odors completely if the source is very strong, they make a significant difference in reducing the ambient smell around the can.

How often do you need to replace odor filters in a trash can?

Most manufacturers recommend replacing carbon odor filters every 1 to 3 months, depending on usage. If your kitchen trash fills up quickly with potent food scraps, you may want to replace the filter more frequently, such as every 4-6 weeks, to maintain maximum effectiveness.

What materials are best for preventing odors from absorbing?

Stainless steel is generally the best material for preventing odor absorption. It is non-porous, so smells have nowhere to seep in. High-density, high-quality plastics are also quite good, but lower-quality, more porous plastics can absorb odors over time, especially if they become scratched.

Are trash cans with tight-sealing lids better for odor control?

Absolutely. A tight-sealing lid is the single most important feature for odor control. It creates a physical barrier that prevents odors from escaping into your kitchen. Models with features like locking mechanisms, overlapping rims, or rubber gaskets are superior for containing smells.

Can I add my own deodorizer to any trash can?

Yes, you can. A simple and effective DIY deodorizer is to sprinkle a layer of baking soda at the bottom of the can or bag. You can also use commercial deodorizing pods that stick to the inside of the lid, or even place a few cotton balls soaked in essential oil (like lemon or tea tree) at the bottom of the can before putting in a new bag.

What are some tips for keeping my kitchen trash can from smelling?

Beyond choosing a good can, take the trash out frequently, especially if it contains food waste. Clean your trash can regularly with soap and water or a disinfecting solution. Avoid putting wet or liquid waste directly into the can; drain it first. Finally, consider composting food scraps to keep the most odor-prone items out of your trash altogether.

Do stainless steel trash cans hold odors less than plastic ones?

Generally, yes. Stainless steel is a non-porous material, which means it doesn’t absorb odors from garbage. Plastic, especially if it gets scratched over time, can be slightly porous and may retain faint smells even after being cleaned. However, a high-quality plastic can that is kept clean can still be very effective at controlling odors.

Conclusion: Our Final Recommendation

After rigorous testing, we confidently stand by our top pick: the simplehuman 50L Semi-Round Kitchen Trash Can. It delivers an outstanding combination of performance, durability, and smart design at a price that represents excellent value. Its secure slide lock is its most compelling feature, offering an unmatched ability to contain odors and thwart even the most determined pets, providing real peace of mind. Coupled with the silent-close lid, dent-proof body, and a strong warranty, it addresses the most common frustrations associated with kitchen trash. If you’re looking for a reliable, effective, and hassle-free solution to keep your kitchen smelling fresh, this is the can to get.

Last update on 2025-10-27 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API