Best Dual Compartment Kitchen Trash Can: Our Top 10 Picks & Reviews

Introduction

Managing kitchen waste and recycling can be a messy affair, often involving multiple bins that clutter valuable floor space. A dual compartment trash can is the elegant solution, streamlining your routine into a single, efficient unit. After extensive testing of various models, we’ve found that the best dual compartment kitchen trash can is the simplehuman 35L Dual Compartment Under Counter Pull-Out Recycling Bin and Trash Can. Its seamless integration into cabinetry, incredibly smooth commercial-grade pull-out track, and durable build quality make it our top pick. It transforms a cluttered chore into a hidden, organized, and effortless process, reclaiming your kitchen’s clean aesthetic.

Our Top 10 Picks for Best Dual Compartment Kitchen Trash Can

#1 simplehuman 35L Dual Compartment Under Counter Pull-Out Recycling Bin and Trash Can – Best for: Seamless Cabinet Integration

The moment we installed the simplehuman 35L Dual Compartment Under Counter Pull-Out Recycling Bin and Trash Can, we understood why it’s a game-changer for kitchen organization. This isn’t just a trash can; it’s a complete waste management system that disappears from sight. The standout feature is its commercial-grade ball-bearing track. The gliding action is exceptionally smooth and satisfying, extending fully to provide complete access to both bins without any sticking or stuttering. Installation was refreshingly simple. The unit arrives pre-assembled, and securing the one-piece track to the cabinet floor with the eight included screws took just a few minutes. We found this design far superior to systems requiring complex assembly. The build quality is immediately apparent, from the sturdy chrome steel frame to the durable plastic bins. The 35-liter capacity is intelligently split, making it ideal for a small household of two or three people who are diligent about taking out trash and recycling. Many users echoed our experience, praising the easy setup and high-quality construction that justifies the brand’s reputation. A crucial piece of advice we share with users is to measure your cabinet space meticulously before purchasing. As some have noted, plumbing or cabinet lips can interfere with a perfect fit, so double-checking your dimensions is key to a successful installation.

#2 simplehuman 50 Liter Semi-Round Kitchen Step Trash Can – Ideal for: Pet Owners and Families

For households with curious pets or toddlers, the simplehuman 50 Liter Semi-Round Kitchen Step Trash Can is an absolute lifesaver. Our primary test for this can was its security, and the slide lock mechanism performed flawlessly. It’s robust and easy to engage, providing total peace of mind that no four-legged friends will be “dumpster diving” while you’re away. This sentiment was confirmed by numerous users who bought this can specifically to thwart their clever dogs. Beyond the lock, the can is thoughtfully designed. The patented “lid shox” technology delivers a slow, silent close that feels premium and prevents abrupt slamming noises. The durable plastic construction is a smart choice; it’s dent-resistant, easy to clean, and lightweight enough to move with the integrated handle. The semi-round shape is space-efficient, allowing it to sit snugly against a wall or island without protruding too much into high-traffic areas. We did note, as did a few users, that the plastic clips holding the lid can wear over time. However, our research found that the brand’s 5-year warranty and responsive customer service often provide a quick and easy replacement, which is a significant plus.

#3 Amazon Basics 50L Foot Pedal Trash Can – Perfect for: Budget-Conscious Style Seekers

The Amazon Basics 50L Foot Pedal Trash Can proves that you don’t need to break the bank to get a stylish and functional kitchen trash can. During our testing, we were impressed by its sleek, modern aesthetic. The brushed stainless steel finish looks far more premium than its price tag suggests and blends seamlessly with other kitchen appliances. The hands-free operation is smooth and reliable; the foot pedal feels sturdy, and the soft-close lid descends quietly without a bang. One of our favorite features is the removable inner bucket. It makes changing bags and cleaning up spills incredibly convenient, a detail often overlooked in budget-friendly models. The stay-open feature is also a great touch for longer food prep sessions. However, we must address a recurring theme in user feedback: shipping damage. Our test unit arrived intact, but a significant number of buyers report receiving cans with dents. While this doesn’t affect functionality, it’s a frustrating flaw in an otherwise excellent value product. The smudge-resistant claim also fell a bit short in our tests; it shows fingerprints more than higher-end models, but they wipe away easily enough.

#4 Amazon Basics Small Pedal Trash Can with Lid – Suits: Bathrooms and Home Offices

While not a traditional kitchen can, the Amazon Basics Small Pedal Trash Can with Lid is an outstanding choice for managing waste in smaller spaces like a bathroom, office, or dorm room. We tested this 20-liter can and found its compact, rectangular shape to be highly efficient, fitting neatly into tight corners. The stainless steel finish gives it a clean, modern look that elevates it above typical plastic office bins. Functionally, it performs well. The foot pedal provides easy hands-free access, and the soft-close lid is a fantastic feature at this price point, preventing any jarring noises. The stay-open functionality, activated by pushing the lid back slightly, is surprisingly useful when you’re cleaning out a desk or clearing off a counter. We also appreciated the heavy-duty plastic inner bucket, which makes emptying the can a clean and simple task. A few users mentioned durability issues with the foot pedal’s plastic components breaking after extended use, which is a point to consider for very high-traffic areas. However, for typical home office or bathroom use, we found the construction to be more than adequate, offering a great balance of features, style, and value.

#5 simplehuman 55L Rectangular Step Trash Can – Best for: High-End Kitchens and Busy Households

The simplehuman 55L Rectangular Step Trash Can is undeniably a premium product, and after putting it through its paces, we can say it largely earns its price. The first thing you notice is the impeccable build quality and thoughtful design. The fingerprint-proof finish actually works, keeping the brushed stainless steel looking pristine with minimal effort. The wide steel pedal is incredibly robust and engineered for longevity, providing a stable and responsive feel with every press. We were particularly impressed by the integrated liner pocket. This feature, which dispenses new bags from inside the can, is a brilliant convenience that makes liner changes faster and more efficient. The steel liner rim that clamps down on the bag is another standout design element, holding the bag securely and keeping it completely hidden for a clean look. The 55-liter capacity, made possible by its bucket-free interior, is perfect for large families or those who generate a lot of waste. A minor point of critique, echoed by a small number of users, is the reliance on plastic components in the hinge mechanism, which can be a point of failure over many years. However, given the brand’s long warranty and stellar reputation, we consider this a minor risk for an otherwise top-tier product.

#6 simplehuman 50L Rectangular Kitchen Step Trash Can – Ideal for: Classic Durability and Function

There’s a reason the simplehuman 50L Rectangular Kitchen Step Trash Can is a long-standing favorite. It’s a workhorse that masterfully combines timeless design with rugged functionality. During our testing, this can felt incredibly solid. The heavy-duty steel pedal is built to last, and the patented lid-shox technology provides a consistently smooth, silent close that never fails to impress. We particularly value the internal hinge design, which allows the can to sit completely flush against a wall, saving precious kitchen space. The removable inner bucket is a key feature for us; it not only makes cleaning effortless but also includes a clever “bucket park” position that holds it slightly elevated for easier bag changes. Many longtime users confirm our findings, reporting that these cans last for over a decade with no issues, a testament to their build quality. The fingerprint-proof finish performs well, resisting smudges and keeping the can looking sharp. While it may not have the fancy liner pocket of newer models, its proven durability, thoughtful features like the stay-open lock, and robust construction make it an excellent long-term investment for any kitchen.

#7 SONGMICS 2 x 8 Gallon Kitchen Trash Can – Perfect for: Dedicated Trash and Recycling Separation

The SONGMICS 2 x 8 Gallon Kitchen Trash Can is an excellent choice for those who want a clear, all-in-one solution for separating trash and recyclables. What we appreciated most during testing was the dual-pedal design. Having two separate, clearly designated pedals prevents cross-contamination and makes sorting mindless. Both lids feature a soft-close mechanism that works reliably, bringing them down gently and quietly. The rigid stainless steel body feels sturdy and looks sleek, while the two removable inner buckets, each with its own handle, make emptying either side a breeze. The 8-gallon (30L) capacity per side is a generous size, striking a good balance for a family kitchen—large enough to avoid constant emptying but not so large that trash sits for too long. The airtight design of the lids also did a commendable job of containing odors. Our experience was confirmed by several users who noted the stylish appearance and practical separation. However, like other stainless steel cans in this price range, we saw numerous reports of units arriving with shipping dents. While our unit was fine, it’s a potential risk for buyers. Overall, if you prioritize clear separation and a modern aesthetic, this is a very strong contender.

#8 Rev-A-Shelf 35 Qt Double Pullout Trash Can – Suits: DIY Kitchen Upgrades

For those looking to create a custom, built-in waste solution, the Rev-A-Shelf 35 Qt Double Pullout Trash Can is a top-tier choice. We installed this unit in a standard base cabinet and were immediately impressed by the quality of the hardware. The full-extension, ball-bearing slides are the star of the show, providing an incredibly smooth and sturdy pull-out motion that feels professional-grade. The heavy-gauge wire frame is robust and holds the two 35-quart bins securely, with no wobble or instability. We found the installation process to be straightforward, requiring just four screws to mount the base to the cabinet floor. This ease of installation was a common point of praise among users, with many noting it was a simple project that significantly upgraded their kitchen’s functionality. The capacity of the two 35-quart bins is substantial, making it a great fit for families who need ample space for both trash and recycling. A minor drawback we noted is that the instructions can be a bit sparse for absolute beginners. However, the design is intuitive enough that most DIYers should have no trouble. This is an excellent, durable system for anyone wanting to get their trash cans off the floor and hidden from view.

#9 iTouchless 50L SensorCan Kitchen Trash Can – Best for: Hygienic, Hands-Free Operation

The iTouchless 50L SensorCan Kitchen Trash Can brings a touch of modern convenience to the kitchen with its reliable motion sensor. During our testing, the hands-free operation was a true benefit, especially when our hands were messy from cooking. The sensor was responsive without being overly sensitive; it opened quickly with a wave of the hand but didn’t trigger accidentally when we just walked by. A feature we found genuinely effective was the AbsorbX carbon odor filter. It did a noticeable job of neutralizing smells, keeping the area around the can fresh. The extra-wide opening is another practical design choice, easily accommodating bulky items like pizza boxes without a struggle. We also liked the retainer ring system, which holds a standard 13-gallon bag securely in place and hides it from view. Our positive experience with the sensor was shared by many users, who love the hygienic, touchless convenience. However, a common long-term complaint is the durability of the battery compartment, which can be prone to corrosion over time. Opting for the AC adapter (sold separately) could be a wise investment to mitigate this. Despite this, for those prioritizing a truly touch-free experience, this can is a leading choice.

#10 Amazon Basics 20L Round Brushed Stainless Steel Trash Can – Ideal for: Small Kitchens on a Budget

The Amazon Basics 20L Round Brushed Stainless Steel Trash Can is a fantastic solution for those with limited kitchen space or who need a smaller secondary bin. We tested this 5.3-gallon can and found it to be a solid performer for its price. Its main strength is its compact, cylindrical design, which can be tucked into a corner or alongside a cabinet without getting in the way. Despite its small footprint, it includes features found in more expensive models, like a quiet, soft-close lid and a durable removable plastic bucket. The foot pedal operates smoothly, providing easy hands-free access. The stainless steel exterior gives it a clean, polished look that is much more appealing than a basic plastic can. Because of its light weight, we noticed it can slide a bit on smooth floors when the pedal is pressed, a sentiment echoed by some users. Placing it on a small mat or adding rubber feet can easily solve this minor issue. While the 20-liter capacity is too small to be the primary can for a family, it’s perfect for a single person, a small apartment kitchen, or for collecting compost or other specific recyclables.

The Ultimate Buyer’s Guide: How to Choose The Right Product for You

Key Factors to Consider

When selecting a dual compartment trash can, consider these essential factors to ensure it meets your household’s needs.

• Capacity and Split: Consider your family’s size and habits. A 50/50 split is common, but some models offer a larger partition for recycling or trash, depending on what you generate more of. Total capacity is typically measured in liters or gallons; a 60L (about 16 gal) unit is a good starting point for a family.
• Opening Mechanism: Step-on pedals are the most common, offering hands-free convenience. Motion-sensor models provide a touchless experience but require batteries or an AC adapter. For a completely hidden solution, in-cabinet pull-out systems are ideal.
• Material and Durability: Stainless steel is popular for its sleek look and durability, but look for fingerprint-proof finishes to minimize cleaning. High-quality plastic is a great alternative as it’s dent-proof, lightweight, and often more affordable.
• Shape and Footprint: Rectangular and semi-round cans can sit flush against a wall, saving space. Slim models are great for tight spaces, while pull-out units free up floor space entirely. Always measure the intended location before buying.

Understanding In-Cabinet vs. Freestanding Units

Choosing between an in-cabinet pull-out system and a traditional freestanding can is a major decision. Freestanding units, like the SONGMICS or many simplehuman models, offer flexibility in placement and generally have a larger capacity. They are easy to set up (no installation required) and come in a wide variety of styles and opening mechanisms. Their main drawback is that they occupy visible floor space. In-cabinet pull-out systems, like the simplehuman or Rev-A-Shelf models, are the ultimate space-savers. They hide your waste completely, maintaining a clean kitchen aesthetic and keeping trash away from pets. The downside is they require installation and sacrifice cabinet storage space. They also tend to have a slightly smaller capacity than the largest freestanding models.

Common Mistakes to Avoid

Avoid these common pitfalls when making your purchase:

• Forgetting to Measure: This is the biggest mistake, especially for in-cabinet units. Measure the cabinet opening’s width, depth, and height, accounting for any plumbing or interior lips. For freestanding cans, measure the floor space and the height under countertops if you plan to tuck it away.
• Ignoring Liner Compatibility: While many cans fit standard bags, some are designed for custom-fit liners. These liners often provide a neater fit but come at a higher cost and are less convenient to purchase. Check if standard bags will work well before you buy.
• Underestimating Capacity Needs: It’s tempting to get a smaller, sleeker can, but if you have a large family, you’ll be constantly emptying it. Be realistic about your waste output to avoid daily frustration.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the ideal capacity split between trash and recycling?

The ideal split depends entirely on your household’s habits. If you recycle a lot of boxes, bottles, and cans, a 50/50 split or even a can with a larger recycling compartment is best. If your household generates more non-recyclable waste, a model with a larger trash bin and a smaller recycling section would be more efficient. Many popular models offer a balanced 50/50 split in a 60-liter (16-gallon) total capacity, which is a versatile starting point for most families.

Are the inner bins removable for easy cleaning?

Yes, almost all high-quality dual compartment trash cans feature removable inner buckets or liners. These plastic bins typically have built-in handles, allowing you to lift them out completely. This design makes it incredibly easy to change trash bags, clean up any spills or leaks, and wash the bins thoroughly without having to move the entire unit.

Can you use standard trash bags for dual compartment cans?

In most cases, yes. While brands like simplehuman design their cans to work perfectly with their own custom-fit liners, standard-sized trash bags (like 8-gallon or 13-gallon kitchen bags) will typically fit. The fit may not be as perfectly snug, and you might have some excess bag to tuck in, but they are almost always a functional and more affordable alternative.

How much space do dual compartment trash cans typically take up?

Space varies by design. Freestanding rectangular models usually have a footprint of around 23 inches wide by 13 inches deep. In-cabinet pull-out systems require a standard base cabinet, typically with a minimum opening of 14.5 inches wide and 22 inches deep. Always check the specific product dimensions against your available space before purchasing.

Are there models with separate lids for each compartment?

Yes. Some models, like the SONGMICS 2 x 8 Gallon Kitchen Trash Can, feature two separate lids, each with its own step pedal. This design is excellent for hygiene as it only exposes the compartment you intend to use and can be better for odor control.

What are the best brands for recycling combo trash cans?

Based on our testing and market research, simplehuman consistently stands out for its superior build quality, innovative features, and long warranties. SONGMICS offers great value with stylish designs and practical features. For in-cabinet solutions, Rev-A-Shelf is a highly respected brand known for its durable and smooth-gliding hardware.

Is it easy to empty one side without disturbing the other?

Absolutely. Because these cans use two separate, removable inner buckets, you can easily lift out the full bin from one side to take out the trash or recycling without affecting the other compartment at all. This independent functionality is a core benefit of the dual-compartment design.

Conclusion: Our Final Recommendation

After rigorous testing and evaluation, our conviction remains firm: the simplehuman 35L Dual Compartment Under Counter Pull-Out Recycling Bin and Trash Can is the superior choice for anyone looking to streamline their kitchen’s waste management. It doesn’t just hold trash; it reclaims your kitchen’s floor space and visual serenity. The decision comes down to its flawless execution of core functions: the commercial-grade ball-bearing tracks provide a glide so smooth it feels luxurious, the pre-assembled unit makes installation a breeze, and its sturdy construction promises years of reliable use. While other cans offer larger capacities or different features, no other product provides such an elegant and effective solution to hiding and organizing both trash and recycling. It is an investment in a cleaner, more efficient, and clutter-free kitchen.

Last update on 2025-10-27 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API